Foreign Policy Experts Believe that the US and South Korea Should Continue to Negotiate for North Korean Denuclearization
|The Korea Times recently interviewed three Korean foreign policy experts about what they thought how a second Trump presidency would impact South Korea. What I found most interesting was not the Trump talk, but how these experts believe negotations with North Korea should continue to be centered around trying to get them to denuclearize:
Q: North Korea’s threat has become sophisticated. And the North had continued to build up its nuclear capabilities to solidify its status as a nuclear power. Given this, do you believe denuclearizing North Korea is achievable? Will there be a need to discard denuclearization negotiations and adopt a new format of disarmament talks?
Kim: Denuclearization is and should continue to be an end goal to achieve. This is a daunting task unprecedented in the history of nuclear arms control and disarmament, but it cannot be given up. If we give up denuclearization, North Korea will be recognized as a de facto nuclear state. And this likely means the beginning of the collapse of the NPT. This is a nightmare for all. If North Korea becomes a nuclear weapon state, this would agitate South Koreans, and public opinion would evolve even stronger in favor of South Korea’s nuclear armament. If South Korea arms itself with nuclear weapons, other countries in the region, such as Japan and even Taiwan, will also feel the need to follow suit. If this happens, not only the U.S. but also China will face unmanageable proliferation risks.
A nuclear-weapon-free North Korea may sound unfeasible at the moment, but we need to keep trying to make it happen. For that, we need to prevail on North Korea to come back to negotiation on the basis that everything should be on the table. This means both of our and their concerns must not be precluded from any negotiation.
Ahn: The importance of the NPT cannot be overstated. When the treaty was proposed by the U.S. in 1960’s, the former Soviet Union was fully supportive because there was a shared belief that the international community needed such a scheme to prevent proliferation. The first survey that asked South Koreans about their opinions about South Korea’s possession of nuclear weapons was released in 2022 and at that time, 76 percent of South Koreans were in favor. The U.S. officials and think tank experts whom I met were stunned whenever they heard about the survey results. Eventually, South Koreans’ overwhelming support for nuclear armament became a type of leverage and convinced the U.S. to team up with South Korea to create the Nuclear Consultation Group (NCG). The NCG is a very useful institution for South Korea and we need to make the most of it to deter North Korea’s threat.
Korea Times
You can read much more at the link, but I just don’t see how you negotiate to achieve something that is not going to happen. Kim Jong-un is not going to give up his nuclear weapons, it is his ultimate regime survival trump card. Plus his nuclear weapons program to continues to make his regime relevant internationally. He has already turned down a deal for denuclearization in return for dropping of sanctions and nothing has changed in the intervening years that would change his mind.
To my knowledge, only a few nations have given up their nuclear weapons. South Africa and Ukraine spring to mind.
How has that helped or hurt them?
FOREIGN POLICY EXPERTS BELIEVE THAT THE US AND SOUTH KOREA SHOULD CONTINUE TO NEGOTIATE FOR NORTH KOREAN DENUCLEARIZATION
That is a divide-by-zero statement.
Anybody who believes that is not an expert.
CH, as I see it, the people who want to continue the charade are paid by the hour with no penalties for failure to deliver success.
When the commies start yapping their stupid shít, I encourage and enthusiastically agree.
At some point, I start enquiring how we will divide the fruits of their labor.
What I learned is that communism doesn’t work that way.
It turns out that all the people pushing communism expect ME to divide the fruits of MY labor.
I see.
Not a good deal, really.
May I buy you a half-way ticket on a helicopter?
CH, that reminds me:
And to the dogs, pigs, cows, and grasshoppers out there—you know who you are, you moochers and looters, may you wake up before it’s too late.
Because a time is coming where governments will run short of everything but you.
And then it’ll be too late.