Does Old Map Japanese Map Show Dokdo as Korean Territory?
|Here is the latest development on the Dokdo front:
An antique map from the 19th century depicting the Dokdo Islands as part of Korean territory has been discovered in Japan.
Nam Kwon-hee, a professor of library information science at Kyungpook National University, said he confirmed a Japanese collector has a hand-drawn map of “Daedongyeojido,” a Korean map made by cartographer and geologist Kim Jeong-ho in 1861 that marks Dokdo to the right of Ulleung Island in the East Sea, according to Yonhap News.
The research was co-conducted with Professor Kim Sung-soo of Cheongju University and professor emeritus Yukio Fujimoto of the University of Toyama in Japan.
The map was originally in the collection of the Pyongyang Provincial Library, but was smuggled out via an unknown route. The atlas has the library’s registration number and Aug. 30, 1932, marked as the date acquired.
Professor Nam estimates that the hand-drawn map including Dokdo was created between 1864 and 1889. The map supplements the woodblock book printed by Kim, which does not mark Dokdo. [Korea Times]
You can read more at the link, but I look at this map and that does not look like Dokdo at all. It makes more sense that the island to the right of Ulleongdo is actually Jukdo Island. The island on the map looks like Jukdo and is located where Jukdo is near Ulleongdo. Also back in the 1800’s no one would have cared about two insignificant rocks in the middle of the Sea of Japan to make them so big on a map like this.
GI I am in thinking you’re right about that being “Juk” Do as it says “in the mountains” east of the mountain icons and that appears on other “Juk” Do maps:
Funny thing, Korea calls that Bamboo Island (“Juk” Do) which in Japanese is Takeshima which is what they now call “Dok” Do which means Lonely Island.
If you’re wondering why I’m Romanizing the Hangul that way it’s to point out that you guys keep saying “Dokdo Island” which would be Dokdodo; “do” means island. Just as annoying as when 2ID’ers say “Hey, let’s go hike up Soyosan Mountain!” “san” means mountain, it’s Soyo Mountain… 😡
By the way since when is 1861 “ancient”? Way to spin the story there Yonhap. :hmm:
ancient
of or in time long past, especially before the end of the Western Roman Empire a.d. 476
Well. the shapes are a bit unrealistic; but the little one does look like one island, not two…
Jukdo: https://www.google.com/maps/place/37°30'00.0%22N+130°52'00.0%22E/@37.5285685,130.9361912,16z/data=!4m5!3m4!1s0x0:0x0!8m2!3d37.5!4d130.866667?hl=en
Liancort Roicks/Dokdo: https://www.google.com/maps/place/37%C2%B030'00.0%22N+130%C2%B052'00.0%22E/@37.2420587,131.8665314,15z/data=!4m5!3m4!1s0x0:0x0!8m2!3d37.5!4d130.866667?hl=en
Dok Do is mine, I but it from a nice Chinese man…..
bought…
It wasn’t this guy was it?
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_kRuD6zV4Fqs/S6175wqO1uI/AAAAAAAACwQ/UmIDEaHiOhA/s400/ishot-434.jpg
As a matter of fact…