UPDATE: The Stars and Stripes has a follow up article on the milblog OPSEC issue which includes yours truly. The article also has quotes from servicemembers in Korea on this issue including this one from a Public Affairs NCO in Seoul I found interesting:
“I think there does need to be some control on the blogs. It’s making our jobs harder because a lot of what is in the blogs feeds into negative press coverage, especially when a soldier is perceived as speaking for the Army. As any American, I chafe against any curtailment of freedom of speech, but as a soldier sometimes you sacrifice your freedoms for the greater good.â€
I think this is an additional problem with the military, that some in the public affairs arena like this NCO, remain critical of milblogs even though the vast majority of milblogs are sending out a pro-military message much more effectively than the military public affairs offices are. I cannot think of one big milblog that is negative against the military, while the big milblogs like Mudville, Milblogs, Blackfive, OP-FOR, etc. continue to provide accurate information about the military and push a pro-troops message to the general public.Â
The Army justafiably has a concern about OPSEC that is addressed with the updated policy, but the solution that this public affairs NCO is suggesting will only surrender the information war that the military is already badly losing.
__________________________________________
I have received a number of e-mails today from people asking me how the new regulation on soldier blogs effects my blog after a lot of hysteria was created by this Wired magazine article claiming that the Pentagon is trying to shut down military bloggers due to concerns about operation security (OPSEC) reasons. To figure out exactly what all the concern is about it is always best to look at the regulations themselves. Here are some passages from the updated Chapter 2 of Army Regulation AR530-1, Operational Security that deals with military blogs:
Here is what the Army is defining sensitive information to be:
Okay I see no problems here with any of this. Now this next passage is where I think a lot of the controversy is coming from:
This passage in the regulation doesn’t make sense when you think about it. According to this passage every time you send out an e-mail much less update your blog you are supposed to get a OPSEC officer to review it? Commanders and OPSEC officers do not have time to check Private Tentpeg’s every single e-mail and stopping Private Tentpeg from sending e-mails to mom and dad is quick way to get a Congressional Inquiry opened on you.Â
Fortunately the Army is issuing a correction on this and clarifying what they meant by this regulation. Here are the highlights from the clarification:
• In no way will every blog post/update a Soldier makes on his or her blog need to be monitored or first approved by an immediate supervisor and Operations Security (OPSEC) officer. After receiving guidance and awareness training from the appointed OPSEC officer, that Soldier blogger is entrusted to practice OPSEC when posting in a public forum.
(…)
• Soldiers do not have to seek permission from a supervisor to send personal E-mails. Personal E-mails are considered private communication. However, AR 530-1 does mention if someone later posts an E-mail in a public forum containing information sensitive to OPSEC considerations, an issue may then arise.
I have had plenty of OPSEC training before and have always used to the rule of thumb to blog only about open source material from sites like Stars and Stripes, Chosun Ilbo, 2ID webpage, etc. I could make this blog a whole lot more interesting if I blogged about FOUO or classified information, but there is no reason for anyone reading this blog to know about these things from me first. If the Army wants to let the public know about these things then they will issue a press release to the media. It is not my responsibility to determine what information needs to be released to the public and if all military bloggers remember that, there shouldn’t be any OPSEC problems. Now back to blogging as usual.
You can read more about this issue at these sites:
Stars and Stripes
Blackfive
Milblogs
Michelle Malkin
OP-FOR